Ex-NYPD Chief Under Federal Scrutiny for Misconduct Allegations

Boat passing under Brooklyn Bridge in New York.

Federal investigation unveils allegations of sexual misconduct against former NYPD Chief Jeffrey Maddrey, casting a shadow over his sudden resignation.

At a Glance

Federal agents searched Jeffrey Maddrey’s residence as part of a criminal investigation.
Maddrey resigned amidst allegations of coercing a lieutenant for sexual favors.
Multiple law enforcement bodies, including NYPD’s Internal Affairs, are investigating.
Maddrey denies allegations, with his lawyer challenging the accuser’s motives.

Federal Agents Conduct Search

Federal agents executed a search warrant at the home of Jeffrey Maddrey, NYPD’s former chief of department. The operation forms part of a broader federal criminal investigation into serious allegations of sexual misconduct leveled against Maddrey. This move followed a complaint lodged with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission by Lieutenant Quathisha Epps’ lawyer, Eric Sanders, accusing Maddrey of quid pro quo sexual harassment.

Amid the investigation, Maddrey suspended his career with NYPD, surrendering his chief position on December 20. His suspension was implemented without pay around the same time federal agents began scrutinizing his residence. Allegations include coercing Epps for sexual favors to secure perks like overtime opportunities. Maddrey, however, refutes these claims, insisting that the accusations attempt to mask the accuser’s potential misconduct.

Top Uniformed N.Y.P.D. Officer Resigns After Abuse Allegations
Jeffrey Maddrey demanded sexual favors, according to subordinates, and the federal authorities are investigating. He had previously been accused of harassment on the job. https://t.co/S2MB5mgJZc via @NYTimes

— Serge Kovaleski (@sergenyt) December 23, 2024

Investigation Led by Multiple Agencies

The complexity of the case involves several investigating bodies, including the NYPD’s Internal Affairs Bureau, the city’s Department of Investigation, and the Manhattan District Attorney’s office. Commissioner Jessica Tisch confirmed the involvement of these entities, stating, “At my direction, the Internal Affairs Bureau of the New York City Police Department is working with law enforcement authorities to investigate allegations against former Chief of Department Jeffrey Maddrey.” Each body aims to dissect the evidence and validate the veracity of Epps’ statements, who ranks among the NYPD’s top earners.

“At my direction, the Internal Affairs Bureau of the New York City Police Department is working with law enforcement authorities to investigate allegations against former Chief of Department Jeffrey Maddrey” – Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch

Reports claim that Maddrey forced Epps to endure threats of retaliation if she resisted his alleged demands. Epps also accuses Maddrey of instigating an unjust overtime investigation against her when she declined his overtures. Nevertheless, Maddrey’s legal team argues that Epps was already under scrutiny for contrary reasons, separate from her harassment claims.

#BREAKING | Former NYPD Chief of Department Jeffrey Maddrey has been suspended after an internal investigation and home searchhttps://t.co/qer3tOeKOI

— PIX11 News (@PIX11News) January 2, 2025

Controversial Resignations Amidst Allegations

Maddrey’s resignation is a continuation of leadership turnover at NYPD in recent times. His supposed ally, New York City Mayor Eric Adams, is also grappling with other federal charges, compounding the tumultuous environment. This series of events raises concerns about internal practices within the department, especially concerning senior officers. As the investigation progresses, sources suggest Maddrey maintained an “office fling” but denies coercive behavior.

Parallel to Maddrey’s situation, Mayor Adams announced a review of the current police commissioner’s overtime spending practices amidst the broader context of department accountability. The unfolding situation echoes prior resignations, notably those of Commissioner Edward Caban and an adviser, Timothy Pearson. As authorities continue their inquiry, the NYPD asserts its commitment to tackling sexual misconduct thoroughly.