Police Officer Smiles During Jogger Killing Confession

crime scene tape with police officers in a park
Photo: Steve Sanchez Photos / Shutterstock

Hours after his arrest, a grinning former New York City police officer told a reporter he killed a Brooklyn jogger—and claimed God told him to do it.

Story Snapshot

  • Police charged Sayed Mohassib, 27, with second-degree murder in the stabbing of Katie Suarez.
  • Court papers say he went to the bike path carrying a knife; video places him near the scene.
  • He later told a newspaper he killed Suarez because “Allah told me to”.
  • A grand jury indicted him; a judge ordered him held without bail.

What police and prosecutors say happened

New York City police arrested Sayed Mohassib after a weeklong search linked to the stabbing death of 28-year-old runner Katie Suarez along the Shore Parkway Greenway in Brooklyn. Officials charged him with second-degree murder, weapon possession, and tampering with evidence. News outlets that reviewed the criminal complaint reported that surveillance video showed him walking toward the path before the attack and leaving after. The complaint also says he went there while carrying a knife that night.

Prosecutors moved fast. A Brooklyn grand jury returned an indictment on the top count of second-degree murder. A judge then ordered Mohassib held without bail. Police described him as a Department of Education school aide who had briefly served as a New York City police officer before resigning in 2022. That work history will draw attention at trial, but it does not change the legal test: prove intent and identity beyond a reasonable doubt.

His statements shifted—then went much further

The complaint summary says Mohassib first denied stabbing anyone. He told investigators he went to the path with a knife because he feared people would kill his family. He also said he later found himself covered in blood, without describing any contact with Suarez. Days later, in a jailhouse interview with the New York Post, he said he killed Suarez because “Allah told me to,” and that the command came two days before the attack.

Jailhouse statements to media can shape public opinion, but they do not replace evidence. A confession to a newspaper is not a sworn plea, and defense lawyers will test its meaning and his mental state. Still, a direct claim of responsibility, tied to a timeline and motive, will loom over any trial. Jurors will weigh it against his earlier denial, the video, the knife claim, and forensic results that may surface later.

The core evidence the jury will likely care about

Jurors tend to focus on five things in a circumstantial murder case: presence near the scene, opportunity, physical evidence, behavior after the event, and statements that fit or clash with the facts. The prosecution already points to presence and statements. Investigators will try to add forensic links like blood on clothing, transfer on a weapon, or phone and location data. Each item must stand on its own and also fit a tight timeline that leaves no real doubt.

Defense strategy often turns on mental state and reliability. Expect questions about delusion, religious fixation, or stress, especially given his claim that God ordered the killing. That path is not a free pass. Insanity defenses are rare and hard to win. The bar is high: prove he could not understand the nature or wrongfulness of his act. Claims that change over time can hurt credibility, unless medical records and expert testimony back them up in detail.

Public safety, simple truths, and what comes next

Runners want to know if it is safe to be out at dusk along city paths. Police presence helps, but policy must start with common sense: better lighting on known routes, working cameras, and quick alerts when a serious crime occurs. Families also want steady justice, not headlines. The clean path forward is clear: present the video, the science, the timeline, and the defendant’s words; let a jury weigh them with calm minds and open eyes.

Sources:

nytimes.com, abc7ny.com, newyork.news12.com, edition.cnn.com, newsweek.com, nypost.com